Sword Fern Research Timeline 2013-2026

A video introduction: one of the last large pure stands of sword ferns at Seward Park.
Four plants died in 2020.
Death moves upslope year by year.
Cause unknown.
Ongoing, summer 2025.
2013 Autumn - Catherine Alexander's Initial Report
The sword fern die-off was first noticed by Catherine Alexander (naturalist and daily visitor to Seward) in the autumn of 2013. Here is her account, offered on October 28th, 2014:

The Sword Ferns near the hatchery and along the northern end of the hidden trail above that area began to fail about a year ago, though the first signs were quite subtle - just a sense that they were somehow sagging, as if they'd been covered with cardboard for a week or two. At the time I estimated that perhaps 40% of the population was affected.

I kept watch over the winter, thinking that what I was seeing was a temporary thing, that the ferns would recover when their fiddleheads appeared in spring. That was not to be. None of the affected ferns produced fiddleheads this spring, and by late spring the remaining fronds withered and died.

By July I noticed that whatever was happening had spread beyond the initial 40%, though it could be that I just hadn't seen the first signs of failure in the seemingly unaffected population. I monitored spore production in and around the affected areas this year, and noticed that many of the apparently healthy individuals either failed to produce sori, or that their sori were sparse and underdeveloped. Many of these individuals failed over the summer.

I haven't a clue as to the cause, though I have been thinking about it. Initially I looked for signs of Aplodontia (mountain beaver) activity, thinking that a new and active colony might be destroying the fern roots. I found none of the signs I would expect from such activity - no burrows, no bitten off fronds - so think that Aplodontia is in the clear, at least this time.

2014 October - video walkthrough of Ground Zero
2014 November - Seattle Parks staff visit affected area
Several members of the Friends of Seward Park (Paul Shannon, Paul Talbert, Al Smith) and Seattle Parks staff (Gail Takeoka, Jeanne Schollmeyer and plant ecologist Jillian Weed) visited the affected area. General puzzlement was shared. Jillian proposed an informal monitoring project: we planted two young sword ferns in December; almost one year later these two ferns are growing slowly and seem to be healthy. I watered them weekly over the dry summer.

Update 2025

Only one of the two "Jillian ferns" survived into the second year and into the present.
2014 December - Jenny Glass Report
As best I recall, I placed a cold call to WSU Puyallup Plant & Insect Diagnostic Laboratory, and then delivered two entire ferns to Jenny Glass. With funding from the Friends of Seward Park, Jenny Glass analyzed two entire ferns (one dead, one still with a few signs of life) in her laboratory in Puyallup. Her report:
Microscopic observations and incubation of the sample in moist chamber have not revealed any evidence of a primary pathogen in the root zone or crown tissue at the soil line. A composite sample of tissue from these areas tested for the Phytophthora pathogen via an Agdia immunostrip test kit was negative for the presence of this disease group (nor do soil conditions seem to be poorly draining, conditions that promote the growth of Phytophthoras). Microscopic investigation of the fronds of the sword fern also have not shown any primary pathogenic activity that would be responsible for the occurrence of this dying patch of plants.
2015 May - Dr. Olaf Ribiero, Plant Pathologist
On another cold call, I enlisted the aid of Dr. Ribiero. Without renumeration, he analyzed diseased sword fern samples in his Bainbridge Island lab, and later visited Seward Park to consult with us. FoSP subsequently gave him a $100 gift certificate to his favorite restaurant.

His report:

I examined the fern samples you brought over. I found a little Rhizoctonia and Pythium in the roots. Both can cause root rot problems in ferns. However, I am not convinced that this is the cause of the problem since both are present in low amounts in the roots. The fronds are infected with Glomerella fungus blight. Again, not in sufficient amounts to cause complete dieback of the frond. No foliar nematodes (a problem reported on ferns), were isolated from fronds tested.

The dieback is more typical of herbicide injury or some other chemical injury. Was any herbicide applied on this area? [We have no evidence for, or report of, herbicides applied here.] Rhizoctonia is a difficult pathogen to control.

2015-2016: Dr. Tim Billo and students: 20 monitoring plots
Under Tim's direction, with contributions from other UW faculty, advice from Seattle Parks plant ecologist Lisa Cieko and Nelson Salisbury of Earth Corps, two undergraduate students (Tristan O'Mara and Kramer Canup) ran a six-month monitoring project.

Report to Seattle Parks Field Committee, June 2016

2015 October - email exchange with Dr. Robbin Moran
Dr. Moran is the Curator of Ferns & Lycophytes at the New York Botanical Garden, author of "A Natural History of Ferns".

I am not sure what could be causing the die-off of Polystichum and have not seen anything like this in other extensive fern populations. I hope you can find out what is happening. It is a curious phenomenon, and worrisome that it might spread elsewhere. The world's expert in the taxonomy of the genus is Dr. David Barrington (dbarring@zoo.uvm.edu), from the University of Vermont, Burlington. Although not a plant pathologist, he might have some insight into the problem.
2015 November - Dr. Marianne Elliott and Jenny Glass: the Phytophthora hypothesis
Tuesday November 10th, Dr. Marianne Elliott and Jenny Glass (Diagnostic Plant Pathologist) braved the traffic and drove up to Seward Park from the WSU Plant and Insect Diagnostic Laboratory in Puyallup.

Accompanied by undergraduate students Tristan O'Mara, Kramer Canup and me, Marianne and Jenny spent a couple of hours inspecting the extended die-off site, and collecting soil and leaf samples from affected sites and a mostly healthy region (Kramer and Tristan's 5x5m "Plot 1").

Jenny describes herself as a lab generalist (a most expert generalist, it seems to me). Marianne is a research plant pathologist who, among other things, has coordinated (and is celebrated for) Washington's statewide response to Sudden Oak Death. She is active in phytophthora research. Though previous tests for Phytophthora came up negative (Jenny in 2014, Olaf Ribeiro in spring 2015) Marianne suggests that a closer and more sustained examination is worthwhile.

The Phytophthora Hypothesis

The site visit resulted in what is, at present, a very tentatively held hypothesis. Marianne noticed small and mostly dead cedar seedlings, about 12 inches tall, each marked with a red-on-white plastic tag, in and around ground zero. We found several of these up above the north-facing ground zero slope, the flat area where Catherine Alexander first noticed signs of distress and die-off.

Failed Planting of 10k Cedars in 2011

Lisa Cieko learned from fellow Parks plant ecologist, Michael Yadrick, that these tagged cedar seedings were among 10,520 bareroot cedars Parks contractors had planted throughout the forest in February of 2011. [Apparently none of these 10 thousand seedlings survived. To my knowledge, Parks did not followup survival studies. pshannon, 2025]

Lisa adds: one article that I found did say that this could be an issue -

Root Rot of Western Swordfern Caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi in California.

The abstract mentions that the "pathogen was inadvertently brought to the site via rhododendron nursery stock".

Thus we have a conjecture, a hypothesis, and the good fortune to also have experts both skilled and experienced to test it out. Their lab methods may also reveal other candidates, may suggest other hypotheses. We are very grateful to Marianne and Jenny!

Marianne's Protocol

Lab Report from Jenny Glass

Result: No support for the Phytophthora hypothesis

2017 February - email from Dr. David Barrington
David Barrington is a Professor of Plant Biology, University of Vermont, now (2025) emeritus. Robbin Moran identified him as the "world's expert in the taxonomy of the [Polystichum] genus".

Here I combine excerpts from multiple emails.

I understand your concern about the sword fern, given the stark pattern you are observing in your part of the world. I have never heard of a blight impacting species of Polystichum so unfortunately I have nothing to offer in the way of insights into what might be at the root of your dieback.

If I had to guess, I would say that the individuals are probably very old, perhaps dating back to the time of original disturbance in the area. This seems likely given that there seems to be little or no sexual reproduction going on, and the mature sporophytes can persists by their perennial and bifurcating rhizomes.

I wonder whether age of an individual close could be extrapolated by trying to determine the size (diameter) of an individual clone and taking into account its annual growth rate. Something like this has been done for Osmunda regalis and Pteridium aquilinum, but I cannot remember the references off-hand. I think one study on Pteridum aquilinum was done by Park and Werth in 1993 near the Mt. Lake Biological Station in Virginia.

I very much like the idea that they are old individuals, established at a remote time when there was disturbance in the forest. Fire would create such a disturbance. As to age, 1000 years is not out of the question, possibly much longer but there are no data at all for deciding. There are very few sites for the establishment of new plants via gametophyte in the stable mature forests of the Northwest, though a single treefall would create such an opportunity. Polystichum munitum is essentially unbranched, which lends support to the idea that the populations are made up of independently originated individuals, not fragments of some giant clone.

2017 February - the drought/climate change hypotheses
We are often asked whether - and it is often suggested - that the PNW lowland sword fern die-off is caused by recent drought or climate change.

We suggest that the following multiple lines of evidence together conclusively establish that direct drought and temperature shifts are not the direct cause of the sword fern die-off.

Indirect climate effects may play a role, in which case the mechanisms and the intermediate processes need elucidation.

"Not Dead Yet"

The single strongest argument against the hypothesis that PNW drought causes sword fern mortality is this 2016 New Phytologist research paper by Jarmilla Pittermann and colleagues:

Not dead yet: the seasonal water relations of two perennial ferns during California's exceptional drought

UW Atmospheric Scientist Joe Zagrodnik examines the data

The first reports in the region of dramatic die-off are from 2010, on the Kitsap Peninsula. See Port Ludlow study, below. UW PhD atmospheric scientist Joe Zagrodnik looked for drought/die-off correlations and reported:

The period from 2007-2012 was generally characterized by near-normal temperatures and precipitation (2011 was a cool year). By all measures the current period anomalous weather started in 2013 and I can say confidently that anything happening prior to 2013 is not caused by unusually warm or dry weather patterns.

Ecophysiology Studies out of Reed College

Reed College ecologist Dr. Aaron Ramirez and his undergraduate student Caleb Goldstein-Miller report that
The ecophysiology analysis of ferns from healthy, intermediate and die-off areas in Seward park [show] that moisture stress is not a driver of physiological stress for Seward ferns.
More detail from Caleb's final report:
For the ecophysiology analysis portion, our hypothesis was that plants in non-die off areas would have higher values for stomatal conductance, Fv/Fm, and possess a ​Ψ​ closer to the optimum for the species in question (or further from the turgor loss point for the local population) in comparison to plants in active die off areas. Three distinct areas of decline were established at Seward Park, die off, intermediate, and healthy.

These areas were characterized with the help of Paul Shannon (Seward Park Steward) and Olga Kildisheva (Verdant Counseling, LLC) and sampled on August 19th, at the peak of the dry season. We used the following metrics to compare physiological stress of ferns in the die off, intermediate, and healthy treatment areas: dark-adapted fluorescence (Fv/Fm) to determine the efficiency of photosystem II, stomatal conductance (Gs) to ascertain whether or not ferns are closing their stomata during photosynthetically active periods, and xylem water potential (​Ψ)​ to determine water status (Toivonen and Vidaver, 1988; Schreiber and Bilger, 1987; Corcuera and Notivol, 2015; Angelopoulos et al., 1996; Jordan and Ritchie, 1971).

Healthy tissue from ten ferns within each treatment group was analyzed for predawn and midday water potential and dark-adapted fluorescence. Stomatal conductance measurements were taken in between predawn and midday sampling. We found no significant differences between treatment groups in any of the metrics except midday water potential. The ferns from the die off treatment area had an average midday xylem water potential of -1.7574 MPa, versus -0.9074 MPa and -0.9474 MPa for the intermediate and healthy treatment groups respectively. This result is complicated by the fact that we ran out of compressed nitrogen during the midday water potential readings from the die off treatment area.

Samples were immediately transported from Seward Park to Reed college in a cooler so that water potential measurements could still be taken. Due to the unstandardized approach in xylem water potential analysis between the die off and the other treatment groups, we cannot be confident of the accuracy of this result. However, a pressure-volume curve was created from samples taken across the three treatment groups, which gave us a turgor loss point of -2.3 MPa for ​P. munitum​ at Seward Park.

Since the significant water potential result was well above this moisture stress-indicating threshold, we are confident in our conclusion that moisture stress is not driving the die off at Seward Park. This increases our confidence that the regional decline is caused by some still unknown biotic vector.

Fort Worden Fern Recovery after Drought

We received in 2017 reports, photos and videos of die-off on Artillery Hill at Fort Warden, outside of Port Townsend, average rainfall about 25 inches. By 2019, all ferns had recovered. We suggest that this is the normal response and recovery of sword ferns to drought stress, as also described in Pittermann 2016. As an ancient and widespread PNW understory plant, it seems likely that it has well-established mechanisms with which to survive drought.

Seward Five-Year Restoration Experiment

We are half-way through a five-year restoration planting experiment at Seward Park, described here. 36 ferns, in three groups, all ferns watered through drought months, show statistically significant survival - correlated with location - in an active die-off zone (low survival), and in area hypothesized to be free of any die-off activity (> 95% survival).

No other plants visibly affected

At Seward Park, and in the other regional die-off sites we monitor (ranging from near Quilcene on the Olympic Peninsula, to the Goldmeyer Hot Springs Road in the foothills of the Cascades) no other understory plants exhibit the die-off or decline symptoms we see in sword ferns. The die-off thus appears to be specific to P. munitum: no other fern species are affected, no other shrub or herbaceous species. It seems unlikely that the sword fern - famously robust and very long-lived ("1000 years is not out of the question" - David Barrington, University of Vermont, Polystichum genus expert) - that the sword fern alone would be affected by drought and temperature.

Patchy Survival

The die-off at Seward Park spreads in two ways: radially from heavily affected areas, and by leaps into distant previously unaffected areas. The radial spread includes movement uphill, jumping across trails after some delay, and downhill into presumably wetter soil. Large regions of low- and high-density fern populations are unaffected - within a short distance of affected areas. This distribution is hard to explain by drought effects. Pathogenicity, perhaps abetted by weather and climate, makes much more sense.

Monthly Precipitation Reports, 2010-2018

Informal Weather Notes Related to Sword Fern Die-off

2017 April - The die-off jumps the sqebeqsed trail
2017 April - New sample collection with Marianne Elliott
2017 May - Hatchery Valley Before and After

The trees in this area are unimpressive, mostly maples < 2' dbh, with incomplete canopy cover. By the end of the summer of 2024 some natural regeneration had taken place here - which is unusual at Seward, where large healthy trees predominate, many of them coniferous, with little open canopy. A casual inspection revealed no new sword ferns. Some nursery ferns planted (in 2018? by Verdant LLC) in straight SE-NW lines seem healthy.

2017 June - Soil Tests
Nelson Salisbury and I collected soil from three locations in Seward's forest: from Ground Zero, from an as yet (but subsequently) unaffected site to the far north, and an intermediate site to the west.

The subsequent testing cannot be characterized as high-grade multi-dimentional assays. The U Mass Soil Nutrient Lab serves primarily gardeners, perhaps some farmers.

Nothing useful came out of this small project.





2017 July - Regional Map of Candidate and Confirmed Sites
Our efforts to track regional (Puget Lowland) spread of sword fern die-off have waxed and waned over the years. Community reports via iNaturalist provide a far better report.

Nonetheless, here is an early map.

2017-2018 Fort Worden State Park, Decline & Recovery

2017 October: die-off report

2018 May

2018 January: The 36-fern (3x12) fern experiment begins
With some guidance from Verdant LLC, and the support of Seattle Parks, Suzanne Bouchard and I planted young nursery sword ferns at and near Ground Zero in Seward Park. This is an ongoing experiment, to last at least three more years. You can read an earlier report here.

The die-off at Ground Zero had reached steady state by 2014, leaving almost entirely bare ground. 10% of the original ferns, as we assessed in a June 2019 study. This quarter acre was subject to erosion and likely undergoing further ecological degradation: underground mycorrhizal networks need photosynthesizing plants, of which there were very few. No natural restoration had taken place until a few fringecups - most happily - appeared in 2019.

Suzanne and planted three lines of 12 ferns, two lines at Ground Zero, 1 line just north of what was then the boundary of the expanding die-off region. I hypothesized that the agent of the die-off, whatever it turns out to be, was no longer active at Ground Zero, but that it was likely to be active and virulent at the die-off's leading edge.

This hypothesis was a generalization from a single fern planted at Ground Zero in 2014. Inspecting the die-off with Seattle Parks plant ecologist Jillian Weed, I asked, "What should we do?". "Monitor closely", she said, "and why don't you plant a couple of nursery ferns?". We did, I watered the pair through a couple of summers, and one (dubbed "Jillian Weed #1") is thriving now six years later. A 50% survival rate for restoration planting is better than I usually achieve. So I surmised that the die-off agent/s were gone - at least temporarily.

I watered all 36 plants weekly during summer drought, two liters per plant, for three summers. The Ground Zero ferns (with one exception) are thriving. The northern line ("ADZ" for active die-off zone) is about 50% dead or dying. I have made every attempt to treat all three lines identically. By 2024, the one questionable ADZ fern has recovered, and is now in good health.

In April, Bonnie Drew, Jeff Kelley and I twice independently surveyed all three lines. We counted fiddleheads, interpreting them as simple markers of overall plant health. Here are the results, summarized for each of the three 12-fern lines, in box plot form. The full dataset is available on request.

I provisionally conclude that there is currently no active agent affecting ferns at Ground Zero. The degraded site is now recovering, which is very fine to see. The agent may return.

Prediction Confirmed by 2022, after four years

As the contiguous die-off spread north, several of the 12 ADZ ferns began to fail within the first year after planting. By 2025, 7 of the 12 are dead, and 2 are in poor condition. (TODO: check these figures in late May, when new growth might appear.)

All 24 GZ ferns are in good health, producing new fronds each year.

2018 July - Miniscule resprouting fronds
2018 July - Port Ludlow Die-off History 2008-2018
This Kitsap Peninsula history provides extra context. Note, especially, that die-off first appears in 2008, well before dramatic weather anomalies appeared in the Puget lowlands.

From: Ellen Theisen and Ken Thompson

We are writing to you in the hopes that you have discovered a remedy for the sword fern die-off, and to share with you some information about our experience and experiments, since we were the first to report the die-off to Jenny Glass and Olaf Ribeiro.

We recently found your blog about the Seward Park sword fern die-off. For 10 years, we have been concerned about the die-off on and around our property, but until now, we didn't know of any others who shared our concern.

1990. The 2.5 acres of our land in Port Ludlow were covered with huge, gorgeous sword ferns, reaching up to nearly six feet high. The 160-acre forest surrounding us was also covered with big, healthy ferns.

2008. We began to notice that the ferns were dying in three or four areas of our property. Within a few years, an entire quarter acre held only dead fern root balls, and no weeds at all, with half an acre more showing severe damage.

July 2013. The die-off had continued to grow with many ferns dying or looking unhealthy. We cleared out a forest of blackberries and salmonberries and discovered another quarter-acre of die-off we had not seen before.

August 2013. We sent samples of some dead and dying fronds, along with a document of many annotated photos, to Jenny Glass and Marianne Powell at the WSU extension, asking for a diagnosis. They responded that the cause was unknown, and that neither they nor other plant specialists at WSU had heard of any similar problem elsewhere.

April 2014. We contacted Olaf Ribeiro. He examined the ferns, and took soil samples to analyze. He found evidence of a spider-mite infestation, but he said that he had not seen this sword fern die-off anywhere else. We cleared up the spider mites by spraying with CG-Mite.

May 2014. We applied organic products that strengthen roots and kill fungus to the soil around approximately 1000 healthy, dying, and dead ferns.

April 2015. We repeated the application. We also transplanted 34 ferns into a 1000 square-foot die-off area, and they are still alive and doing fairly well.

2017. We transplanted 8 ferns into another 400-square-foot area, and they have grown fiddlebacks this spring, and most of them look healthy.

Current. We have seen signs of improvement. Ferns are even beginning to grow in the first die-back area we observed. However, an occasional fern still dies or looks unhealthy, and the 160-acre forest surrounding us is showing signs of severe die off. The 10 acres we have walked through are full of dead and dying ferns.

If you find any solution to the die-off, please let us know as soon as possible. We will, of course, be watching your blog and would be happy to send you any of our documentation.

2018 Autumn - Dr. Rodrigo Valverde, LSU plant virologist
Dr. Rodrigo Valverde, LSU Plant Pathologist and author of a 2009 paper describing a dsRNA virus infecting ferns, generously responded to my inquiry, and after viewing the video, suggested:

Via Email

I have over 30 years of experience dealing with plant diseases, most of them viral diseases and diseases of unknown cause. After looking at the photographs, my first impressions (in order of most likely to less likely) are: 1, fungal, bacterial, or nematode disease; 2, physiological stress (lack/excess of water, pH imbalances, acidic most likely caused by acid rain); 3, viral disease. As you can see, I placed viral disease last because it is rare that viruses kill plants. However, the fern virus I worked with tend to cause a slow decline and eventually death on ferns. I did not mention insects or other arthropods damage but that is something that cannot be ruled out. However, a careful inspection will answer that.

I would rather make a "guess" based on actual/live inspection of the problem, but if I have to make a guess from pictures, I will guess a fungal or bacterial pathogen. This is because of the apparent pattern/distribution of the dead plants.

Site Visit, December 2018

My first impression of the die-off is that it seems to be a typical disease caused by a plant pathogen. The symptoms are typical of bacterial, oomycetes, or a root pathogen.

The die-off appears to be occurring in isolated spots but expanding. Not sure if it occurring “away” from the walking pathways. This needs to be determined because it may provide evidence of the disease origin.

Non symptomatic plants were showing foliar damage typical of an herbivore such as thrips. Many leaves showed discolorations and leaf spots.

Symptomatic plants consisted of total necrosis. What appears to be early symptoms begins with death of the lower leaves. This advances until the whole plant is death. This “apparent early symptom” may rule out a root pathogen.

The putative pathogen appears to be dispersing aerially.

I suggest attempts to isolate a pathogen from plants showing early symptoms of die-off. Transplanting heathy plants near disease plants and monitoring them is a good idea.

Examinations of ferns near Lake Crescent (Olympic National Park) yielded some herbivore damage, foliar discolorations and some leaf spots. However I did not see any ferns with die-off symptoms.

2018 September - Ecophysiology Study, Kildisheva et al.

SWORD FERN ECOPHYSIOLOGY REPORT 2018 – SEWARD PARK, WA

Olga Kildisheva, Kramer Canup, Natalie Schwartz, Tim Billo, and Matthew Aghai

The full report is available here

(Note: this study, and the subsequent Doty project, were both commissioned by Seattle Parks at a time when Parks staff were committed to the drought hypothesis. For reasons stated above - see section titled "2017 February - the drought/climate change Hypotheses" - heavy skepticism is warranted. See especially Haven Ecology's report, below, in the section titled )

Overview
Seward Park has been experiencing a decline in Western sword fern (Polystichum munitum) populations since 2013. Efforts to investigate the cause of the decline have not been conclusive to date, yet the severely impacted areas of the park are now in need of follow-up restoration. To determine whether sword fern recovery is possible at sites that have experienced complete die-off, we examined the survival and growth of planted sword fern seedlings at “Ground Zero” (the epicenter of the sword fern decline at the park) and two more nearby locations. Additionally, to understand the physiological status of stands of sword fern throughout the park, we set up a network of monitoring plots to survey existing sword fern plants in various stages of decline. All measurements were standardized across the three study areas to establish a baseline data set for referenced over time. We treated “plot types” as separate measurement area and therefore experimental findings are primarily reported on a plot type basis (Figure 1). This is the first series of studies conducted at Seward Park that examined the mechanisms and dynamics behind sword fern decline and recovery using a physiological approach.

2018 October - the beer bottle experiment.
An informal experiment suggests that the agent/s of the die-off can be reproducibly transmitted from an affected frond to a healthy one via water.

This informal experiment suggests that the agent/s are mobile in water, and will affect healthy fronds sharing water with a diseased frond, especially when the diseased fond is at the "crinkly phenotype" stage (which may be the earliest stage of the presumed infection).

Be warned! This experiment is exceedingly preliminary, undoubtedly naive, suffers from small sample sizes, has not been replicated, and includes no quantitative data nor microbe-scale assays. They have been carried out by an untrained enthusiast.

The relevant section starts at 11 minutes, 10 seconds.

The transcript (edited)
Dylan Mendenhall's introduction: Paul provided the first preliminary evidence that the blight is probably caused by a pathogen in a pilot study. Paul's account: I plucked a dozen fronds from the forest. Six of them were from healthy plants. Six of them were from diseased plants. I brought them home, cleaned out six beer bottles, filled them with tap water. I stuck different pairings of the fronds into different bottles: half of the bottles had a healthy/healthy pair. The other half of the bottles had a healthy frond paired with an affected frond. I watched them over three weeks, photographing them to keep a record. Somewhat to my surprise, we got a result. We found that, after three weeks, in the healthy/affected bottles the healthy fronds looked like the diseased frond. Meanwhile in the healthy/healthy pairings, the fronds had wilted a little bit - as you might expect after three weeks in a beer bottle - but they were distinctly different from the affected/healthy pairings. This suggests that there may be a waterborne pathogen which had moved within the bottle, from the affected frond to the healthy one.

2019 March - First (and only) signs of natural regeneration at Ground Zero.
2019 March - Seattle Times Magazine story

The Case of the Vanishing Ferns: Citizen sleuths can’t figure out what’s killing Seattle’s sword ferns

Seattle Times journalist Sandi Doughton and photographer Erika Schultz have published a magnificent article on the regional sword fern die-off. Their grasp of the science, the historical context, the social interactions, the politics and complexity of grassroots activism - is, in so many ways, skillful, on point, and insightful. They tell our story better than we ever could.

Read the story from the Pacific NW Magazine - which may now be behind a paywall.

2019 May - A study of the 20 out of 215 (9%) of ferns that survived at Ground Zero
In 2013, 215 large healthy sword ferns occupied the understory of the quarter-acre of Seward Park's Ground Zero. Twenty of those ferns survive six years later.

Is there a pattern to that survival, perhaps some clue to the cause of the die-off?

It appears that proximity to trees or logs correlates with survival - but does that stand up to close inspection? We found that there is a small but statistically significant association.

In this map dead ferns are black circles, survivors are in light green, trees are larger solid circles, and logs are thick black lines.

Leo Shannon and I collected the location and status of all ferns, trees and logs in this quarter acre on May 18th and 19th, 2019. Dylan Mendenhall did the analysis. Results are summarized below the map.

2019 May - Crozier Study, David Perasso

A Possible Symptom of the Die Off, David Perasso May 17, 2019

Full document (PDF)

Since April 15 of this year, I have been monitoring 9 sword ferns in an active die off area at Seward Park. The purpose of the monitoring is to document the progression of the die of by tracking changes in ferns as they die. It is hoped that a set of definitive symptoms will be found that can help identify die off sites.

Already there are some observations which, taken together, seem to be a significant symptom of the Seward die off syndrome:

2019 June $8000 donation from Seattle's 100 Women Who Care

We used this generous donation to hire Dylan Mendenhall to carry out greenhouse transmission experiments and endophyte DNA sequencing.

See these projects described below:

2019 November - Greenhouse Transmission Experiment, Dylan, Marianne, Paul

Sword ferns from the Seward Park die-off site can induce wilting and obstruct water uptake in healthy ferns

Dylan Mendenhall, Marianne Elliott and Paul Shannon

November 2, 2019

pdf

Abstract

The regional decline of sword ferns (Polystichum munitum) in the Puget Sound lowlands remains unexplained. However, anecdotal observations and some preliminary evidence from a pilot study suggest that a transmissible pathogen may be driving the phenomenon. We used sword fern fronds as a bioassay in a paired-sample greenhouse experiment to determine if symptoms could be transmitted from symptomatic fronds to healthy fronds with water as a shared medium. After 5 days, fronds in the infected treatment group were significantly more desiccated and had significantly lower foliar moisture content than fronds in the control group which were grown in water with apparently healthy fronds. We were not able to identify whether the causal agent was transmitted through physical contact, an aboveground vector or through the water. Nonetheless, our results suggest that a vascular pathogen is present in the foliage of sword ferns located at the edge of an active die-off site in Seward Park
2020 January - Dead fern mapping at Seward
Selected subregions only: this was not a comprehensive tour of all parts of Seward's forest.

I was initially motivated by my observation that in the bounded 5-acre region in the middle of the map, fern die-off had not yet progressed as much as I had seen both south and north of that central region. This appears to have been borne out.

I traversed sections of the forest, collecting a GPS location on every dead fern crown I encountered.

See section below 2020 October - Die-off hits an old pure stand of ferns, one of the last unaffected which finding confirms that this bounded section, at that point, had markedly less die-off, but now has considerably more.

The northern end of the bounded region still shows less than typical die-off.

2020 August - the Doty Report
(Note: this study, as with the Kildisheva report, was commissioned by Seattle Parks at a time when Parks staff were committed to the drought hypothesis. For reasons stated above - see section titled "2017 February - the drought/climate change Hypotheses" - and mindful of the risks of motivated reasoning, possibly in play in any contracted work, skepticism may be warranted.)

Molecular and Microbiological Approaches to Address Western Sword Fern Decline

Principal Investigator: Professor Sharon L. Doty
Research Scientist: Andrew W. Sher pdf
Abstract
In the last decade, there has been a rapid decline of western sword fern (Polystichum munitum) throughout the Puget Sound region. Preliminary data suggested an infectious agent as the cause, however, results were not definitive. We propose to use molecular and microbiological approaches to determine the probable cause of the mortality. Phase 1 objectives are to verify that inoculum from affected plants causes decline of healthy fern, and subsequently, to analyze the inoculum using PCR, sequencing, microscopy, and microbiological screening techniques to determine the pathogen identity. For a subsequent Phase 2 grant, we will propose to use plant microbial mutualists for biocontrol and increased resilience of western sword fern plants. Our current suite of microbial strains with strong activity against Rhizoctonia and other fungal pathogens will be tested for activity against the fern pathogen. The ability of the biocontrol strains to colonize and persist in fern will be ascertained. In parallel, the microbiota of fern naturally surviving in the decline zones will be screened for activity, purified, and identified. The overall aim of the full project is to provide a natural protective inoculum for use in restoration of western sword fern.

FoSP expressed reservations about the conduct, content and conclusions of this report. Our concerns included:

  1. Doty and Sher did not engage with FoSP, Mendenhall, Billo or Elliott in preparing for or carrying out this project.
  2. They assert that any putative pathogen "currently only remains in the environment in small numbers" and that "without active spread, identification of a pathogen is unlikely". Had they consulted with FoSP, they would have learned that the die-off is ongoing, very active and widespread in Seward's forest.
  3. Regarding the authors' claim "The results from the three experiments did not support the hypothesis that fern decline is caused by a transmissible agent", we suggest that their failure to accomplish transmission may have multiple causes. The absence of evidence (by their methodology) is not evidence of absence. Note that our "evidence of transmission" was the differential appearance of wilting in experiment vs control samples, in the ad hoc beer bottle experiment, and then again in Dylan's greenhouse experiments.
  4. When questioned about the 36-fern experiment, and its support for pathogenicity, Doty replied - again, without evidence - that soil type differences explain the dramatic difference in survival across these two sites.
  5. At the conclusion of our zoom meeting to review this report, invited guest Nelson Salisbury of Earth Corps said, "I hate to say this, but I see the die-off everywhere, in all soil and forest conditions". Nelson has the trust and confidence of Seattle Parks staff, and this remark appeared to have reduced the tenacious hold of the drought hypothesis.
2020 September - Sword Fern Microbiome Project: Preliminary Findings, Haven Ecology
Prepared for the Friends of Seward Park, by Dylan Mendenhall and Andres Barrera
Full Report (pdf)

Sword ferns (Polystichum munitum) are rapidly declining in Seward Park, one of the few remnant old growth forests in the Puget Sound lowlands. Based on recent transmission experiments, we hypothesize that a pathogen may be responsible for the phenomenon. We also consider drought stress as an alternative explanation. We compared areas of Seward Park containing symptomatic sword ferns with areas of Seward Park and Schmitz Preserve Park containing healthy ferns. In each experimental group, we surveyed the soils, site conditions and plant communities. We also collected tissue samples from sword ferns to measure their foliar moisture content and to evaluate the microbial endophyte community using the Illumina MiSeq platform.

Foliar moisture content was significantly lower in symptomatic sword ferns compared with healthy ferns. However, foliar moisture content was not correlated with soil moisture content, which was similar between all three experimental groups. Soil bulk density was also similar between the symptomatic and healthy areas of Seward Park. Widespread mortality was not observed among sword ferns in Schmitz Preserve Park, where the soils are more coarsely textured and better draining than in Seward Park. Although the microbiome component of our study is ongoing, these preliminary results do not support the drought hypothesis.

The sword fern decline is likely driven by a process that is independent from the site conditions that influence soil moisture content.

2020 October - Die-off hits an old pure stand of ferns, one of the last unaffected
2021 March - Unscuccessful Endophyte DNA Sequencing, Mendenhall & Lekberg
Ecologist Dr. Ylva Lekberg of MPG Ranch carried out - pro bono - amplification, sequencing and analysis of fern tissue collected at Seward by Dylan Mendenhall. Unfortunately, samples were poorly chosen, failing to include a sufficient number of affected and unaffected leaf tissue. Results were inconclusive.

Lekberg and Dupre's final report is available here.

2021 - Dylan Mendenhall's research report: Evaluating the relationship between soil moisture and the withering ferns of Seward Park
Full report

Abstract
Sword ferns (Polystichum munitum) are rapidly declining in Seward Park, one of the few remnant old- growth forests in the Puget Sound lowlands. Based on recent transmission experiments, we hypothesize that a pathogen may be responsible for the phenomenon. However, other studies suggest that the phenomenon is driven by seasonal drought stress, mediated by local site conditions that influence soil moisture. We compared areas of Seward Park containing symptomatic sword ferns with areas of Seward Park and Schmitz Preserve Park containing healthy ferns. In each experimental group, we surveyed the soils, site conditions, and plant communities. We also collected tissue samples to measure the foliar moisture content of sword ferns, and to compare their microbial endophyte communities using the Illumina MiSeq platform. Foliar moisture content was significantly lower in symptomatic sword ferns compared with healthy ferns.

However, foliar moisture content was not correlated with soil moisture content, which was similar between all three experimental groups. Soil bulk density was also similar between the symptomatic and healthy areas of Seward Park. Widespread mortality was not observed among sword ferns in Schmitz Preserve Park, where the soils are more coarsely textured than in Seward Park. Although the microbiome component of our study is ongoing, our preliminary results remain consistent with the pathogen hypothesis. Our findings suggest that the sword fern decline is driven by a process independent of drought stress or the site conditions that influence soil moisture content.

2022 May - Tim Billo's Second Presentation to the WNPS
Update on Seattle Area Sword Fern Die-off, Dr. Tim Billo
Aug 2024 - Feb 2025 - Second unsuccessful contract with Dylan for sword fern endophyte sequencing Full history here
2024 January- Daniel Harm's Film

18 minute version

2:37 version

2025 March - iNaturalist Sword Fern Die-off Project
Community reports via iNaturalist provide our best current sense of the regional spread.
2025 March - A introduction to the problem for Seward Park visitors
This is still in draft form, with improvements coming soon. Viewer beware! Suggestions welcome.

But please do follow the link, then take a look at the time-lapse video of the current most virulent die-off site.

FoSP will soon place this poster into one or more of the Seward Park kiosks.

The QR code points to this website.

2025 June - Looking for Endophyte Sequencing Advice
We hypothesize that recent regional, novel sword fern (Polystichum munitum) mortality may be due to a perturbed fern microbiome. We therefore seek advice on enodphyte sequencing - of fungi, bacteria and oomycetes. We understand that sequencing is unlikely to yield quick and clear results. Perhaps an exploratory pilot study will be the place to begin.

Brett Younginger has the only published P.munitum endophyte sequencing we have identified. Fungi were his exclusive focus. Interestingly, and probably relevant to any study we do, he reports in two successive papers that

  1. An initially highly diverse populuation is, by June, reduced to one dominant species.
  2. That persisting dominance is due to repeated colonization over the growing season.
  3. "repeated sampling should be the standard in endophyte studies, because single sampling events are not sufficient to capture the dynamic nature of these cryptic microfungi."
  1. 2017: Fungal endophyte communities in the temperate fern Polystichum munitum show early colonization and extensive temporal turnover
    Summary
    PREMISE OF THE STUDY: Fungal endophytes have been shown to colonize all land plants, yet surprisingly little attention has been given to their community composition in ferns. We examined the diversity and temporal turnover of fungal endophytes in foliar tissue of the temperate western sword fern, Polystichum munitum , comparing taxa in newly emerged leafl ets and in the same fronds after 1 mo of exposure in the fi eld.

    METHODS: Utilizing next-generation sequencing, we sampled pinnae from P. munitum in spring, 2–3 d after they emerged. We additionally sampled pinnae 30 d later from the same fern blades. From these samples, we sequenced fungal DNA to characterize the initial colonization and temporal turnover of endophytes in the host.

    KEY RESULTS: We demonstrate that P. munitum is abundantly colonized by endophytes in newly emerged foliar tissue. However, 1 mo later, the community composition undergoes a marked shift: the overall richness of endophytes increases, but the evenness of the community wanes as a single taxon, Flagellospora fusarioides , comes to dominate.

    CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that P. munitum hosts a variety of fungal endophyte taxa, similarly to other land plants. However, the rapid shift of the endophyte community we report is an unprecedented observation. Therefore, we further conclude that repeated sampling should be the standard in endophyte studies, because single sampling events are not sufficient to capture the dynamic nature of these cryptic microfungi.

    KEY WORDS culture-independent; Dryopteridaceae; fern microbiota; Flagellospora fusarioides ; microbial community ecology; microbiome; Nectriaceae; Pacifi c Northwest; plant–microbe interactions; western sword fern

  2. 2022: Stable Coexistence or Competitive Exclusion? Fern Endophytes Demonstrate Rapid Turnover favoring a dominant fungus
    Abstract
    Fungal endophytes are critical members of the plant microbiome, but their community dynamics throughout an entire growing season are underexplored. Additionally, most fungal endophyte research has centered on seed-reproducing hosts, while spore-reproducing plants also host endophytes and may be colonized by unique community members. In order to examine annual fungal endophyte community dynamics in a spore-reproducing host, we explored endophytes in a single population of ferns, Polystichum munitum, in the Pacific Northwest. Through metabarcoding, we characterized the community assembly and temporal turnover of foliar endophytes throughout a growing season. From these results, we selected endophytes with outsized representations in sequence data and performed in vitro competition assays. Finally, we inoculated sterile fern gametophytes with dominant fungi observed in the field and determined their effects on host performance. Sequencing demonstrated that ferns were colonized by a diverse community of fungal endophytes in newly-emerged tissue, but diversity decreased throughout the season leading to the preponderance of a single fungus in later sampling months. This previously-undescribed endophyte appears to abundantly colonize the host to the detriment of other microfungi. Competition assays on a variety of media types failed to demonstrate that the dominant fungus was competitive against other fungi isolated from the same hosts and inoculation onto sterile fern gametophytes did not alter growth compared to sterile controls suggesting its effects are not antagonistic. The presence of this endophyte in the fern population likely demonstrates a case of repeated colonization driving competitive exclusion of other fungal community members.
2025 June - Google Map Combining iNaturalist Reports with Washington State Park boundaries
the map
2025 July - Google Map, Narrative & Data on Puzzling "Split Site" - a natural experiment?
the map
2026 April - Douglasia Article: UW Students Traveled 1000 miles throught the Puget Lowlands Documenting Die-off
The Joural, see Page 19
2026 May - California Plant Pathologists tentatively identify a vascular pathogen
The CDFA plant pathology lab (California Department of Food and Agriculture) got interested in the sword fern die-off, joined us in the research October of 2025. We shipped them 30 pounds of fern plants, roots, rhizome and soil. Working pro bono, they found evidence of a vascular pathogen, but could not narrow down genus and species due to limits on the DNA extraction.

Last week we sent them two additional ferns, one sick, one healthy, for a closer inspection.

These good scientists have earned our gratitude. Generous donations to FoSP paid the not inconsiderable bill for overnight shipping.

2026 June - Crowd-sourced photos identify time of disease appearance
The problem: our California pathologists, examining samples from October, predict the presence of a vascular pathogen. But they did not have sufficient affected tissue to extract identifying DNA. So I have been on the lookout for expansive necrosis, starting in September 2025, with no success yet. This week I looked at our community supplied photographic record.

We selected eleven photos from 664 photos contributed by 409 visitors, and learned that symptoms of the die-off appear - in at least this one instance - in June and July.

Mortality Timeline